CalCentrist.org
Home Issues Book Reviews Blog Resources Contact Us
   

We vote on election day; special interest lobbies vote the remaining 364 days.

After the 2008 economic collapse the financial industry has spent over a billion dollars lobbying to water down financial regulation.

Special Interest contributions are small compared to the benefits they get at taxpayer expense.  We need to change this equation.

 

 “I hope we shall crush in its birth the aristocracy of our monied corporations which dare already to challenge our government to a trial by strength, and bid defiance to the laws of our country.”  Thomas Jefferson, letter to George Logan, Nov. 12th, 1816

 

I see in the near future a crisis approaching that unnerves me and cause me to tremble for safety of my country; corporations have been enthroned, an era of corruption in High Places will follow, and the Money Power of the country will endeavor to prolong its reign by working upon the prejudices of the People, until the wealth is aggregated in a few hands, and the Republic destroyed.
Abraham Lincoln,  letter to Col. William F. Elkins, Nov. 21, 1864

I again recommend a law prohibiting all corporations from contributing to the campaign expenses of any party….Let individuals contribute as they desire; but let us prohibit in effective fashion all corporations from making contributions for any political purpose, directly or indirectly.
Theodore Roosevelt, address to Congress, December 3, 1906

 

This site has stopped updating the issues because special interest money is thwarting any serious solutions.  Until the ability of special interest money to buy elections and votes is addressed, progress will be very difficult on the issues. Click here for: The main page of the old site.

We know something is wrong with our political system when we can’t stop the mentally ill from buying automatic weapons because of the NRA lobby, can’t evaluate teachers based on whether their students learn because of the teachers unions, can’t pass effective financial reform after the worst meltdown since the Great Depression because of the financial lobby, and have cities going bankrupt because they can’t rein in public union pensions. 

When the NRA targets ads against representatives who put students ahead of weapons manufacturers, and when the teacher's unions freeze out representatives who dare to put students ahead of incompetent teachers, there should be a fund a public money so they can defend themselves.

Example problems that can’t be resolved because of special interests

Problem

Special Interest

Need for Good Teachers

Teachers Unions.
They oppose pay based on quality, frustrating good teachers who then leave.  An army of sympathetic-appearing teachers and money can be mobilized to thwart any effort at reform.

Gun Control

NRA
This once laudable organization for gun safety had a hostile takeover decades ago, and now  targets for defeat members of Congress that dare to challenge them.

Public Pension Reform

Public Unions
They are bankrupting our governments to maintain much higher benefits than the rest of us get.

Financial Industry Accountability

Big banks
Do we really need to explain this one?

 

 

 

In the early days of baseball, players could be bribed to throw a game by gamblers because the payoff was much higher than their salary.  Higher baseball salaries today make them much less susceptible to bribery.  For Congress, we taxpayers only cover a portion of their expenses with the salaries we pay.  The cost of running for re-election dwarfs their salaries, leaving them susceptible to the same influence – money to throw the game.  In 1974, the average spent to run for re-election in Congress was $56,000.  By 2008 it had increased to $1.3 million.  Also, it has been estimated that representatives spend 30% of their time raising money.  

The Solution

The solution to special interests buying our representatives is obvious – let’s outbid them.  Instead of having our representatives on the payroll of special interests, corporations and unions, let’s put them on our payroll for all of their expenses, so they really work for us.

We’re willing to pay $750 billion to support democracy in Iraq, but not a few billion to reclaim it at home.  Plus, every dollar we spend on public financing of campaigns can eliminate 99 dollars of spending on special interests.

The cost of public funding would be more than covered by the potential cut back on pork Congress doles out to contributors and the waste resulting from their addressing special interests instead of the people.  A similar benefit is postulated for California campaigns

See http://fairelectionsnow.org

In California, see California Clean Money Campaign

Sign the Petition on Change.org to Fix Congress:

California State Legislature: Vote for a Constitutional Convention to fix Congress - End the Special Interest Stranglehold

Summary

This petition asks the California legislature to vote for a special constitutional convention limited to proposing amendments to end the special interest stranglehold on Congress by:

1.  End Gerrymandering - Independent commission to set Congressional District boundaries. 
2.  End Filibuster & allow 45% of the House or Senate to force a vote without amendment.
3.  Public financing of Congressional campaigns. 
4.  Overturn Citizens United – Allow Congress to regulate political spending by organizations.
5.  All lobbying of Congress should be public, and members and staff of Congress should not be able to work as lobbyists for 5 years after leaving office. 
6.  Change House terms from 2 to 4 years so they aren’t constantly running for office. 
7.  Require balanced budget over business cycle (show balance over period of years)

Description

Before we can change our laws, we need to change how laws are made.  Special interests now rule this country, not the voters.  They manipulate the vote and manipulate Congress.  Arcane rules allow a minority of extremists to hijack Congress.  Our system has gotten out of balance in the 200+ years since its founding.  We need to restore the original checks & balances envisioned by the founders.  The basic system of 3 branches of government in balance was designed to make change difficult.  It ceases to work if additional hurdles are added (filibuster, gerrymandering, etc.).  We need to allow the majority to govern, and vote them out if they do a bad job.

These additional hurdles provide more tools to special interests.  Special interests have the money and resources to already have an advantage in our society.  But with our current system, they can donate money and influence government to get subsidies and further advantages.  This is leading to an increased disparity in wealth, which is destroying the middle class, which is thus ruining our economic engine of our consumer economy. 

Congress won’t fix itself, so we need to, through the states.  The constitution allows the states to call a convention to amend the constitution.  The Constitution protects against a convention going beyond its special purpose – any amendment proposed must be approved by ¾ of the states.

 

Proposed Amendments to be drafted in Constitutional Convention:

1.  End Gerrymandering - Independent commission to set Congressional District boundaries.  The incumbent state legislatures now set boundaries in most states, using odd, gerrymandered shapes to insure their reelection.  As a result, in some states where only 40% of the voters vote for the incumbents, the incumbents still win 60% of the seats.  Essentially, politicians and special interests are choosing their voters.  As a result, we get safe districts for each party which leads to only the primary mattering.  This results in electing extremists from both parties since they don’t have to appeal to moderate voters, leading to stalemate in Congress.  For more info. see, e.g., www.endgerrymandering.com

2.  End Filibuster & allow 45% of the House or Senate to force a vote without amendment. The Senate filibuster rules have gotten ridiculous, allowing a minority to block all legislation.  They even allow a single senator (single special interest) to just threaten a filibuster to kill a bill.  A majority of the House would vote to avoid a government shutdown, but the rules allow a minority to prevent such a bill from being voted on.  Congress won't fix itself because senators love that they each have this power to override the wishes of the majority of the American people, and special interests love to get unrelated amendments tacked onto other bills.  For more info. see, e.g., http://fixthesenatenow.org/,      http://killfil.com

3.  Public financing of Congressional campaigns.  Candidates must raise more money each year to get elected.  They have to get this money from special interests, which then want favors and special access - their salary is minuscule compared to the amount of money needed to get elected.  This system for Congress is like paying police officers only a fraction of what they need, and telling them to make it up by shaking down businesses for protection money.  This amendment would also provide public funds to counter independent attack ads.  The tax money spent would be dwarfed by the savings from reducing the need to provide special interest subsidies.  By requiring only public funds for campaigns, contributions by lobbyists and government contractors (a soft bribe) can be shut down.  For more info. see, e.g., www.publicampaign.org

4.  Overturn Citizens United – Allow Congress to regulate political spending by organizations.  The Citizens United Supreme Court case tossed out campaign finance laws that attempted to regulate political spending by corporations, unions and other organizations.  This has made a bad problem worse, allowing special interests to essentially manipulate the public and destroy members of Congress who vote their conscience.  For more info. See, e.g.,
 http://legalnewsline.com/news/244278-new-legal-initiative-formed-to-help-fight-citizens-united-ruling

5.  All lobbying of Congress should be public, and members and staff of Congress should not be able to work as lobbyists for 5 years after leaving office.  While we should preserve free speech and the right to petition the government, we should be able to hear what is being said.  Special interests spend lots of time lobbying behind closed doors after getting access with campaign contributions, or the promise of a high paying job after Congress. Many in Congress use their position as a stepping stone to a much more lucrative lobbying job after they leave government.   For more info. See, e.g.,
http://www.psmag.com/politics/how-to-reform-lobbying-transparency-34112/ and
http://www.republicreport.org/2012/make-it-rain-revolving-door/

6.  Change House terms from 2 to 4 years.  Representatives are campaigning non-stop and thus constantly need to please special interests.  For more info., see, e.g., http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2013/01/house-representatives

7.  Require balanced budget over business cycle (show balance over period of years).  The US debt is currently nearly 17 trillion dollars.  The total US tax revenue for 2013 is projected to be a record $2.7 trillion, but that is dwarfed by the debt.   An annual balanced budget would be economic suicide, but the budget should be balanced over an extended period.  Deficits would be allowed during recessions, wars and other emergencies.  Surpluses would be required during good times.  Balancing the budget in recession years would prolong the recession - money needs to be spent on unemployment benefits, food stamps and stimulus.  But this spending should stop and be repaid during economic boom times.   Every deficit budget should include a plan for how it will be paid back in 5-10 years.   For more info. see, e.g.,
http://www.nationalreview.com/agenda/274257/structurally-balanced-budget-reihan-salam

 

Notes.  A couple notable changes are not proposed.  E.g., term limits have been counterproductive, and are not suggested [see, e.g.:
 http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/05/08/term-limits-encourage-legislative-myopia-and-jeopardize-fiscal-health-study/ ]

 

 

Home | Issues | Book Reviews | Blog | Resources | Contact Us

 

Our system for Congress is like paying police officers only a fraction of what they need, and telling them to make it up by shaking down businesses for protection money.

 

Sunset provisions to end laws sounded like a good idea, but they have been used to solicit contributions from the special interests benefiting from the extension.

Every $1 in lobbying for special tax code provisions can return $6-20 in targeted tax benefits

 

 

 

Copyright 2008 Calcentrist.org - All rights reserved.